Chapter 5 - THE WOODEN BOX AND THE MISSING SEVENTEEN YEARS
“Rebecca, don't sign anything,” Alessandro said.
His voice came through the phone as Rebecca sat on her bedroom floor beside the locked wooden chest.
“I haven't,” she whispered.
“Is Victoria there?”
“Downstairs with her father.”
“Listen carefully. The adoption document they showed you may be part of a scheme to take my sister's inheritance. I need you to protect yourself first.”
Rebecca closed her eyes.
“That's why they brought me here?”
“It's one reason.”
“I thought maybe I finally belonged somewhere.”
Alessandro couldn't immediately answer.
Rebecca continued.
“When your mother looked at me, I knew she didn't believe it. But I kept hoping she might change her mind.”
“You didn't do anything wrong by wanting a family.”
“She looked terrified of me.”
“She was terrified of what you represented.”
Rebecca wiped her cheeks.
“I don't want her money.”
“I believe you.”
“Then help me find Daniel.”
“I will.”
Alessandro paused.
“But I need you to leave that house.”
Rebecca looked toward the bedroom door.
Charles had stationed a private guard near the rear entrance.
And Victoria had taken her car keys.
“How?”
“Don't try to force your way out. Tell them you want a lawyer of your own before discussing the paperwork. I'm contacting the police about your brother and asking them to check on you.”
Rebecca swallowed.
“And the box?”
“Keep it with you.”
Twenty minutes later, Charles Whitmore entered Rebecca's room.
He found her sitting in the armchair, the wooden chest hidden beneath a blanket.
“I understand you've been speaking to Alessandro.”
Rebecca stood.
“He wants to help Daniel.”
Charles studied her.
“I've been helping Daniel for years.”
“Then let me see him.”
“Your brother needs routine.”
“He needs his sister.”
Charles rubbed his forehead.
“You've become emotional.”
Rebecca gave a short, humorless laugh.
“I've been told my whole life I'm emotional whenever I ask a question.”
Charles looked at the unsigned acknowledgment on her desk.
“Sign that, and you'll have everything you need.”
“Does everything include Daniel?”
Charles didn't answer.
Rebecca pushed the paper toward him.
“Then I'm not signing.”
For several seconds, his expression remained unreadable.
Finally, he picked up the document.
“Your mother would have been disappointed.”
Rebecca flinched.
Charles noticed.
“My mother taught me not to sell people,” she replied.
Something moved in his eyes.
Then he turned and left.
At the Romano estate, Claire examined the photograph Rebecca had sent.
The blue ribbon was frayed at one end.
Its faded edges reminded her of the decorations her mother kept in an old sewing basket.
“My mother used to mend things instead of throwing them away,” Claire said.
Alessandro sat across from her in the study.
“She was keeping the key for Margaret.”
“I think so.”
“Did Ruth ever explain why she left it with you?”
“She said some doors only open when the right people stop being afraid.”
Claire looked embarrassed.
“She liked sayings.”
Alessandro almost smiled.
Then he saw the exhaustion on her face.
“You should go home to Noah.”
“My sister is staying with him.”
“That doesn't mean you shouldn't be there.”
Claire looked at her bandaged hand.
“When Noah was injured, everybody told me to focus on what he couldn't do.”
“How did it happen?”
“A car accident. A driver ran a stop sign. Noah was in the back seat with his father.”
Alessandro waited.
“His father died,” she said.
The room went quiet.
“My husband, Michael, was a school bus mechanic. He came home smelling like engine oil and always forgot to take his boots off.”
She smiled faintly.
“Noah still keeps his dad's old baseball cap under his pillow.”
Alessandro looked away.
He knew how grief could turn an ordinary object into something sacred.
“I'm sorry.”
“People say that a lot.”
“I imagine.”
“The thing I wish they'd say is that Noah's still Noah.”
Alessandro looked back at her.
Claire continued.
“He has a different body now. Some things are harder. But he's funny and stubborn, and he loves dinosaurs. He's not a tragedy.”
“No,” Alessandro said. “He isn't.”
For the first time, Claire saw not the feared head of the Romano family but a man who had spent seventeen years living beside an empty place at his mother's dinner table.
The next morning, detectives arranged for Rebecca to leave the Whitmore townhouse.
Charles insisted she was free to go.
Rebecca didn't argue.
She carried the wooden chest and one suitcase.
When Alessandro met her in a supervised interview room at the police station, she looked as though she expected him to reject her.
Instead, he offered a chair.
Claire sat beside him.
Rebecca noticed the blue ribbon hanging from Claire's hand.
“You have the key?”
Claire nodded.
“Can we try it?”
Rebecca set the chest on the table.
Claire inserted the brass key.
It turned smoothly.
The lid opened.
Inside lay a baby blanket, a tarnished silver bracelet, three old photographs, and an unused train ticket.
Rebecca carefully lifted the bracelet.
It was small enough for a newborn.
A hospital identification plate had been fastened to its center.
FEMALE INFANT — ROMANO.
Below it was a six-digit medical identification number.
Alessandro reached for it.
Then stopped.
“May I?”
Rebecca nodded.
He held the bracelet in his palm.
For seventeen years, his mother's stories had been the only proof of Isabella's brief existence.
Now he was holding something that had once circled her tiny wrist.
Claire unfolded the train ticket.
It was issued for a trip from Boston to Portland, Maine.
The date was November 6, 2009.
Two days after Isabella's reported death.
“Somebody traveled with her,” Claire whispered.
Rebecca examined the photographs.
One showed Margaret Hale standing beside an older woman outside a little white house.
Another showed the same woman holding a baby wrapped in a blue blanket.
On the back was written:
Evelyn and our little star.
The third photograph was different.
It showed a young woman standing on a beach, holding a child who appeared to be about four years old.
The image was dated 2013.
The child's face was turned away.
But a blue ribbon was tied around her wrist.
Rebecca frowned.
“I've seen this house.”
Alessandro looked up.
“Where?”
“My mother took me there once when I was little. I remember the porch. There were painted stars on the steps.”
“Where was it?”
Rebecca studied the photograph.
“Maine. Somewhere outside Portland.”
Claire turned over the train ticket.
A handwritten name was printed beside the seat number.
Evelyn Rowan.
Alessandro looked at the photograph.
Then at the bracelet.
“Evelyn Rowan,” he repeated.
Rebecca nodded.
“She used to send Christmas cards to my mother.”
“Do you remember an address?”
“No. But Margaret kept the cards.”
“Where are they?”
Rebecca hesitated.
“In her storage unit. Charles paid the rent.”
Alessandro leaned forward.
“Then we'll ask the detective to help obtain them lawfully.”
Rebecca's expression changed.
“You're not going to make Charles tell you?”
“No. I want evidence he can't take back.”
The Whitmore Foundation's financial records revealed another problem.
Daniel Hale's treatment facility had been receiving payments from a foundation account controlled by Charles.
But the most recent invoice didn't match the facility Rebecca remembered.
It listed a residential program outside Worcester.
Alessandro arranged for a social worker and the appropriate authorities to verify Daniel's location and welfare.
When Rebecca learned this, she began crying.
Not because Daniel had been found.
Because somebody was finally treating him like a person instead of leverage.
That afternoon, Elena met Rebecca again.
This time, Victoria wasn't present.
Rebecca stood awkwardly beside the hospital bed.
“I understand if you don't want to see me.”
Elena reached out.
“Come closer.”
Rebecca obeyed.
Elena studied her face.
“You look like Margaret did at your age.”
“She was my mother.”
“Yes.”
“She loved me.”
“I know.”
Rebecca's lips trembled.
“I didn't steal Isabella's name.”
Elena began to cry.
“No, sweetheart. You didn't.”
For several moments, they simply held hands.
Then Rebecca showed Elena the photographs.
The older woman's gaze stopped on the white house.
Her fingers tightened around the picture.
“Evelyn,” she whispered.
“You know her?” Alessandro asked.
Elena nodded.
“She was Margaret's older sister.”
“Did she raise Isabella?”
“I don't know. Margaret told me Isabella had gone somewhere safe. Your father refused to tell me where.”
Alessandro crouched beside her.
“Mom, why didn't you go to the police?”
Elena looked at him with terrible sadness.
“Because your father told me if I exposed the arrangement, the men threatening our family would find our baby.”
“And you believed him?”
“I had already received a photograph of your school playground with a threat written across it.”
Alessandro went silent.
He had been twelve.
He remembered the extra guards.
He had never understood why his mother stopped allowing him to walk to school.
Elena squeezed his hand.
“I thought silence would keep both my children alive.”
Then she looked at the photograph again.
“There's something wrong.”
“What?”
Elena pointed at the beach picture.
“That little girl is wearing Isabella's baptism ribbon.”
Claire leaned closer.
“How can you be sure?”
“I stitched a tiny silver star onto the end.”
Claire examined the faded ribbon in the photograph.
A silver star glimmered near the child's wrist.
Elena began shaking.
“That's my daughter's ribbon.”
Alessandro studied the date.
2013\.
His sister would have been four.
Someone had photographed her alive four years after the family buried an empty coffin.
But the discovery raised a more frightening question.
Who was the young woman holding her?
Rebecca touched the photograph.
“I know her,” she whispered.
“Who?” Alessandro asked.
“That's Evelyn's daughter, Laura.”
“Where is Laura now?”
Rebecca stared at him.
“She disappeared when I was sixteen.”
Alessandro felt his stomach tighten.
“What happened to her?”
“Margaret told me Laura was in prison.”
“For what?”
Rebecca swallowed.
“Taking a child who didn't belong to her.”
Then she turned the photograph over.
May you like
Beneath the date, barely visible in faded blue ink, somebody had written:
IF THEY COME FOR ISABELLA, TELL HER TO RUN TO LAURA.
